Chattanooga school bus driver found guilty of 6 students’ deaths in crash
A bus driver on trial for his role in the death of six elementary school students was found guilty Thursday on numerous charges stemming from a crash in November 2016.
Johnthony Walker was transporting 37 students from Woodmore Elementary School in Chattanooga, Tennessee, when the bus he was driving flipped over and crashed into a tree, killing six children between the ages of 6 and 10.
Walker originally faced 34 charges, according to online court records, including six counts of vehicular homicide, but was found guilty on six lesser charges of criminal negligent homicide.
He also faced a variety of assault charges, in addition to one charge of reckless endangerment, one charge of reckless driving and one charge of the use of a portable electronic device by a school bus driver.
Walker pleaded not guilty to the negligent homicide charges in March 2017, CNN affiliate WTVC reported.
During the trial, prosecutors argued Walker was driving well over the 30 mph speed limit and was on his phone when the school bus ran off the road.
“It all could have been avoided if Johnthony Walker had slowed down and gone the speed limit and stayed off his phone,” prosecutor Crystle Carrion said, according to WTVC.
Walker took the stand Wednesday to defend himself, saying a white vehicle had encroached into his lane and he swerved to avoid it.
“I chose to veer out of the way,” Walker said. “I figured I had gotten out of the way of the other vehicle and our route would continue.” He added that he was not on his phone at the time of the crash and did not remember how fast he was going.
“Mr. Walker and I are disappointed about the ultimate verdict, but thank the jury for their hard work and deliberation in this case,” said Amanda Dunn, Walker’s attorney, in a statement Friday. “We will now begin to prepare for sentencing, and hope the families and children affected will continue to heal from this tragic accident.”
Defense highlighted mystery white bus
Dunn said on WTVC that Chattanooga police didn’t investigate the case properly. She said they didn’t interview witnesses at the scene and jumped to conclusions rather than letting facts develop.
Dunn said as Walker was driving the bus, a white “transport type of vehicle” was driving in the opposite direction and came around a curve in the road going into the same lane as Walker’s bus.
“There was never an investigation about the white bus, there was never any attempt to take evidence from the roadway or speak to any eyewitnesses about this white bus,” Dunn said. “There was never an investigation on any of the facts that would have led to a conclusion other than the one the Chattanooga Police Department had already made about Johnthony.”
During her cross-examination of Chattanooga Police Investigator Joe Warren, Dunn asked about his investigation methods.
“If I was going on only tire marks, that’d be one thing, but there are other indications that speed was a factor,” Warren said.
He said in December 2016 he estimated the speed of the bus at between 50 and 52 mph, about 20 mph above the posted speed limit.
Other witnesses at the scene, such as state witnesses Ann Jones Pierre and Michelle Brogdon, said Walker was going fast.
“He left the stop sign a little fast,” Pierre said. She lives in the neighborhood where the crash took place and was driving behind Walker’s bus before the crash, WTVC reported.
“You could tell he was going over the speed limit,” Brogdon said. She lived near the crash site, according to WTVC, and rushed to the scene when she heard the crash.
In addition, investigators discovered that Walker wasn’t driving on his designated route when the crash took place. However, in court on Wednesday, Walker said that older drivers gave him a route sheet, but that the route had since changed as certain students had been added or taken off the route.
On phone with colleague from another job
Prosecutors said Walker was on the phone with Takiesha Nixon for four minutes before the bus crash. The two worked together at Amazon, Walker’s second job.
Nixon said as soon as she learned Walker was driving a bus during their phone conversation, she hung up. Dunn said during Nixon’s cross-examination that she didn’t know Walker was involved in the crash until much later.
Sentencing for Walker is scheduled for April 24.
The breakdown of the jury’s verdict was:
• Guilty on 6 counts of criminal negligent homicide
• Guilty on 11 charges of reckless aggravated assault
• Guilty on 7 charges of assault
• Guilty of reckless endangerment
• Guilty of reckless driving
• Guilty of the use of a portable electronic device by a school driver
• Not guilty on 6 counts of assault